Dan has been involved in theater since 2003 with Burlington County Bridge Players production of The Complete History of America as Assistant Director. Since then he has appeared in worked on the following productions:
At the Burlington County Bridge Players he assistant directed Arsenic and Old Lace. He acted in A Christmas Carol, Exit Date, and Don’t Dress For Dinner.
He acted in The Champagne Charlie Stakes at the Hanover Street Theater.
He acted in the following shows at Burlington Country Footlighters: The Nerd, Dangerous Liaisons, The Boys Next Door, Assassins, As Bees in Honey Drown, Rumors, Legally Blonde, And The Winner Is, Glengarry Glen Ross, The Foreigner, Rabbit Hole and The Fox on the Fairway.
He also produced Metamorphosis.
Mr. Brothers graciously consented to an interview on 7/7/17. An edited transcript of our conversation follows.
Critique Compendium: In a recent interview, Al Krier expressed some pretty strong thoughts about you. He said, and I quote, “Dan is the best! I will share a stage with him anytime. He is very generous as an actor.” Do you agree?
Dan Brothers: Vice versa. Al’s a good friend. Playing opposite him is cake. I’m very comfortable working with him.
You have no choice but to raise your game around him. He’s one of that select few that do that. He’s that good. It’s a joy to work with him. Kudos.
In Glengarry Glen Ross we were both funny together. It gelled. Sometimes you know you got it. With that show we both knew we had it.
Critique Compendium: What was it like to perform in shows directed by your wife, Valerie Brothers?
Dan Brothers: It’s a good time. It’s fun, but different. She’s allowed to come down on me much more because I’m her husband. She comes down on me anyway. (Laughs.)
She’s a perfectionist. I’ve known her for 11 years. When she does a project she’s all in.
We have different ways of preparing. The clash can be fun and challenging at the same time.
She really takes care of a script. She does extensive preparation. Eight to 12 months out, she has something laid out.
The Nerd was the first show I auditioned for at Footlighters. I got the lead and at the first read through with the cast I learned that there’s a surprise ending regarding my character. That’s the first time I knew about the ending because I didn’t read the entire script before auditioning. Pretty sad isn’t it.
I’m the very opposite of Valerie.
Critique Compendium: Your character in The Fox on the Fairway had quite an infatuation with Elizabeth Deal’s character. Did having your wife as the director influence your performance in any way?
Dan Brothers: Not in the slightest. Liz and I became good friends over the last few years. We got to know each other quite well during Rumors.
That’s one of the unseen things that happens in community theatre. Meeting people and making friends is the best part. It’s the best reward.
There was no uncomfortableness during that show.
Critique Compendium: You’ve worked as an assistant director in the past. Have you ever considered directing yourself?
Dan Brothers: I’ve daydreamed about it. I don’t know when it’s going to happen. It could be a couple of years from now.
Critique Compendium: You’ve also performed on stage with your wife, Valerie, most recently in Rumors. The two of you also played a married couple in Exit Date. What’s it like sharing the stage with your spouse?
Dan Brothers: That’s a good time. We met during The Nerd and would laugh and flirt quite a bit…we still do that.
Critique Compendium: In the scene where yours and Al Krier’s character made the bet in The Fox on the Fairway, how did you keep a straight face? Between his silly sweater and the tone of voice he used, that must’ve been difficult.
Dan Brothers: Good question. There’ve been so many moments like that. What happens for me is I get the laughs out of the way during rehearsal.
When it’s “game time” you’re conscious of the fact people paid to see the show. People should see us performing to the best of our abilities.
On stage, I’m more focused on staying in character. I find that more difficult that not laughing or giggling.
I’m actually more nervous about misspeaking a line or stuttering than laughing.
Critique Compendium: You’ve performed with Mr. Krier regularly. You also played the male lead in his directorial debut, Rabbit Hole. Was it any different working with him as a director?
Dan Brothers: Yes. That show was extremely rewarding. Al’s a very laid-back individual and that was exactly how he directed. I was very grateful to be cast in that show.
People are familiar with me playing funny roles. I remember a compliment Brenda Kelly Bacon gave me after seeing Rabbit Hole, she said something to the effect: “When you first came out I expected to laugh but as the show went on I forgot I was watching you.” Those are the compliments that really hit home.
I love getting laughs, but if I can move people it’s that much more rewarding because it’s not something I normally do. I’ll always cherish the role for that reason.
Critique Compendium: In Rabbit Hole, you played a father struggling to cope with the loss of his four-year-old son. The scene of you watching the videos of him really moved me. How did you condition yourself to get through that a show that emotionally demanding every night?
Dan Brothers: I take personal experiences. Not all our days are happy. Many years ago I lost someone very close to me. I resort to what it was like to lose her.
It’s got to be unbelievably devastating to lose a child. I’m not a parent, but I do know what loss is.
When you’re on stage you want to do the best you can. I drew on my personal experiences to drive it home.
In The Boys Next Door I played a boy abused by his father. My mother said there were a couple of times during the show there was silence instead of applause after a scene I was in and that in itself is the audience’s reaction to what they just witnessed. I learned in that show that silent audience is actually high praise.
It’s quite something to get that reaction.
Critique Compendium: Rumors featured an abundance of slapstick humor. You played a physically demanding role in that show. In fact, the character you played got hit by a door and even broke his nose. How did you prepare for it?
Dan Brothers: I drank lattes and sat on the couch.
To the kids who want to get into theatre: don’t prepare like Dan. I really don’t prepare. That should prove helpful for any future directors who might consider casting me.
You’ve got to listen to your director. Scott (Angehr) casts you because you earned it. Now you’ve got to prove it to him. You’ve got to prove him right.
Take the vase toss and “one more time” in the Fox on the Fairway. In “one more time” we reenacted the show in three minutes. It comes down to rehearsals.
I can be a real bitch when I’m rehearsing. During “one more time” there was a lot of bumping and dropping things. You just keep going even if there’s a mistake.
As far as the vase toss goes the vase never dropped. Liz (Deal) made a catch like Odell Beckham, Jr. one night, but the vase never dropped.
You rehearse the hell out of it and get it right.
Critique Compendium: You and Rachel Comenzo played a married couple in Rumors. What was it like playing opposite her?
Dan Brothers: She’s a delightful young woman. She’s great to work with. Rachel and I would actually find time alone to run lines and ideas about our characters together which really made our first scene together very strong and enjoyable. She’s great to play against.
With that show our characters didn’t go on stage until 45 minutes in. Backstage, we’d play games. Liz’s (Deal’s) character didn’t enter until late into the second act. We all had a blast. The show was a great time.
Critique Compendium: One of your strongest traits is your voice. You can do soothing baritone. You can also broadcast very well. Is that something you were born with or did you develop it?
Dan Brothers: My parents gave me my voice. I use it a lot. Some might say too much. It’s cool to have compliments on my voice.
Critique Compendium: What first interested you in the performing arts?
Dan Brothers: Chicks. (Laughs)
Kevin Esmond and I went to high school together. The guy’s amazing. Holy Cross was doing a show of Anything Goes. Kevin rattled names of girls involved in the theatre. I decided to try out and got cast. It was amazing. There was tap and singing in the show. I never thought I’d do it.
I returned to South Jersey from Florida in 2006 and once again Kevin reached out to me to asst. direct Burlington County Bridge Players production of Arsenic and Old Lace. I’ve been involved in community theatre since.
Critique Compendium: What types of things interest you in playing a role?
Dan Brothers: Quite a bit. My roles have been very diverse. Howie (in Rabbit Hole) and Bingham (in The Fox on the Fairway) were very different. I’d have to say it has to be someone I can relate to in a pretty good way.
In Rabbit Hole, for instance, while I’m not a parent, I do know how to be a good husband. The character had a desire to seek affection elsewhere. That’s very foreign to me because of Valerie. Ultimately, he wanted to be with his wife. I know how to be a good man.
Valerie is greatest thing that happened to me. I’m crazy about this woman. I like bringing that into a character.
Rabbit Hole was very real and needed to be performed as such. I didn’t want to make fun of this character.
Rebekah (Masters) and I had a scene where we really laid into one another. We worked very hard with Al and Val to make sure we got it right. It really worked. That was my favorite scene in the show.
Quite frankly it’s hard to specify what turns me on to a particular role.
Critique Compendium: What’s been you’re favorite role that you’ve performed so far?
Dan Brothers: I’d have to pick more than one.
Rick Stedman in The Nerd. I don’t toot my own horn very often, but there are times when you know you’ve got a character locked in and this was certainly one of those times.
Howie Corbett in Rabbit Hole is another one, for reasons I mentioned earlier.
Barry Klemper in Boys Next Door. He’s a great character. It wasn’t even the one I wanted in the show. But getting cast as Barry was wonderful learning experience. That’s where I learned drama can be as rewarding as making someone laugh. It was a good lesson.
Critique Compendium: What’s the most difficult role you’ve played?
Dan Brothers: I had a hard time with Henry Bingham (The Fox on the Fairway), but I wouldn’t say it’s the most difficult. I find comedies easier than dramas.
I had to sing two lines in Legally Blonde which was actually quite nerve-wracking since I’m not musically gifted.
I would probably say Barry. It took me a while to learn. I didn’t get the part I auditioned for but I needed to get over it. The show dealt with some pretty tough issues in a direct way and also a lighthearted approach. It’s a beautifully written show and will always be grateful for being a part of it.
Critique Compendium: What actors have influenced you?
Dan Brothers: Jack Nicholson. He was in my favorite movie, The Shining. Talk about natural ability! The guy just knows how to do it. He can convey so much without ever saying a word.
Critique Compendium: If you had the opportunity to work with any other actor either living or dead, who would it be?
Dan Brothers: Nicholson. I would love to work with him. It would be very intimidating but very cool as well.
Critique Compendium: What do you do when you’re not on stage? What are your hobbies?
Dan Brothers: Golf. Val loves it. She has cats. I have golf. It works beautifully.
Critique Compendium: How do you balance a career, family and other activities with the demands of performing in community theater productions?
Dan Brothers: It’s pretty easy for me. I’ll separate work from theatre. I get in game mode for theatre.
These days I’m getting my lines down quicker. If you have lines down faster, it gives you more time to work on the role. I like playing with the role. When you’re in a show your wife is directing, you have to get your lines down quicker.
Critique Compendium: What adjective would best describe your theater career?
Dan Brothers: Rewarding. It’s all been rewarding.